Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

Jenkins X

148
361
+ 1
16
Red Hat OpenShift

1.2K
1.3K
+ 1
506
Add tool

Jenkins X vs OpenShift: What are the differences?

Developers describe Jenkins X as "A CI/CD solution for cloud applications on Kubernetes". Jenkins X is a CI/CD solution for modern cloud applications on Kubernetes. On the other hand, OpenShift is detailed as "Red Hat's free Platform as a Service (PaaS) for hosting Java, PHP, Ruby, Python, Node.js, and Perl apps". OpenShift is Red Hat's Cloud Computing Platform as a Service (PaaS) offering. OpenShift is an application platform in the cloud where application developers and teams can build, test, deploy, and run their applications.

Jenkins X can be classified as a tool in the "Continuous Integration" category, while OpenShift is grouped under "Platform as a Service".

Some of the features offered by Jenkins X are:

  • Automated CI and CD - Rather than having to have deep knowledge of the internals of Jenkins Pipeline, Jenkins X will default awesome pipelines for your projects that implements fully CI and CD
  • Environment Promotion via GitOps - Each team gets a set of Environments. Jenkins X then automates the management of the Environments and the Promotion of new versions of Applications between Environments via GitOps
  • Pull Request Preview Environments - Jenkins X automatically spins up Preview Environments for your Pull Requests so you can get fast feedback before changes are merged to master

On the other hand, OpenShift provides the following key features:

  • Built-in support for Node.js, Ruby, Python, PHP, Perl, and Java (the standard in today's Enterprise)
  • OpenShift is extensible with a customizable cartridge functionality that allows developers to add any other language they wish. We've seen everything from Clojure to Cobol running on OpenShift.
  • OpenShift supports frameworks ranging from Spring, to Rails, to Play

"Kubernetes integration" is the primary reason why developers consider Jenkins X over the competitors, whereas "Good free plan" was stated as the key factor in picking OpenShift.

Jenkins X and OpenShift are both open source tools. It seems that Jenkins X with 2.81K GitHub stars and 499 forks on GitHub has more adoption than OpenShift with 915 GitHub stars and 563 GitHub forks.

According to the StackShare community, OpenShift has a broader approval, being mentioned in 50 company stacks & 52 developers stacks; compared to Jenkins X, which is listed in 3 company stacks and 7 developer stacks.

Advice on Jenkins X and Red Hat OpenShift
Needs advice
on
CircleCICircleCIGitLab CIGitLab CI
and
Jenkins XJenkins X

We are a mid-size startup running Scala apps. Moving from Jenkins/EC2 to Spinnaker/EKS and looking for a tool to cover our CI/CD needs. Our code lives on GitHub, artifacts in nexus, images in ECR.

Drone is out, GitHub actions are being considered along with Circle CI and GitLab CI.

We primarily need:

  • Fast SBT builds (caching)
  • Low maintenance overhead (ideally serverless)
  • Everything as code
  • Ease of use
See more
Replies (3)
Glenn Gillen
Recommends
BuildkiteBuildkite

I think I've tried most of the CI tools out there at some point. It took me a while to get around to Buildkite because at first I didn't see much point given it seemed like you had to run the agent yourself. Eventually it dawned on me why this approach was more ingenious than I realised:

Running my app in a production (or production-like) environment was already a solved problem, because everything was already in some form of "everything as code". Having a test environment where the only difference was adding the Buildkite agent was a trivial addition.

It means that dev/test/prod parity is simple to achieve and maintain. It's also proven to be much easier to support than trying to deal with the problems that come with trying to force an app to fit into the nuances and constraints that are imposed by the containers/runtime of a CI service. When you completely control all of the environment the tests are running in you define those constraints too. It's been a great balance between a managed service and the flexibility of running it yourself.

And while none of my needs have hit the scale of Shopify (I saw one of their engineers speak about it at a conference once, I can't find the video now though 😞) it's good to know I can scale out my worker nodes to hundreds of thousands of workers to reduce the time it takes for my tests to run.

See more
Recommends
jFrogjFrog

I would recommend you to consider the JFrog Platform that includes JFrog Pipelines - it will allow you to manage the full artifact life cycle for your sbt, docker and other technologies, and automate all of your CI and CD using cloud native declarative yaml pipelines. Will integrate smoothly with all your other toolset.

See more
Estu Fardani
Recommends
GitLab CIGitLab CI

more configurable to setup ci/cd: * It can provide caching when build sbt, just add this section to yml file * Easy to use, many documentation

Weakness: * Need use gitlab as repository to bring more powerful configuration

See more
Get Advice from developers at your company using StackShare Enterprise. Sign up for StackShare Enterprise.
Learn More
Pros of Jenkins X
Pros of Red Hat OpenShift
  • 7
    Kubernetes integration
  • 5
    Scripted Pipelines
  • 4
    GitOps
  • 98
    Good free plan
  • 62
    Open Source
  • 46
    Easy setup
  • 42
    Nodejs support
  • 41
    Well documented
  • 32
    Custom domains
  • 28
    Mongodb support
  • 27
    Clean and simple architecture
  • 25
    PHP support
  • 21
    Customizable environments
  • 11
    Ability to run CRON jobs
  • 9
    Easier than Heroku for a WordPress blog
  • 7
    Autoscaling
  • 7
    Good balance between Heroku and AWS for flexibility
  • 7
    Easy deployment
  • 6
    PostgreSQL support
  • 5
    Free, Easy Setup, Lot of Gear or D.I.Y Gear
  • 4
    Shell access to gears
  • 3
    High Security
  • 3
    Great Support
  • 2
    Its free and offer custom domain usage
  • 2
    Logging & Metrics
  • 2
    Meteor support
  • 2
    Overly complicated and over engineered in majority of e
  • 2
    Golang support
  • 2
    Secure
  • 2
    Because it is easy to manage
  • 1
    No credit card needed
  • 1
    MultiCloud
  • 1
    Runs Anywhere - AWS, GCP, Azure
  • 1
    This is the only free one among the three as of today
  • 1
    Great free plan with excellent support
  • 1
    Autoscaling at a good price point
  • 1
    Easy setup and great customer support
  • 1
    Cloud Agnostic

Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions

Cons of Jenkins X
Cons of Red Hat OpenShift
  • 1
    Complexity
  • 2
    Decisions are made for you, limiting your options
  • 2
    License cost
  • 1
    Behind, sometimes severely, the upstreams

Sign up to add or upvote consMake informed product decisions

What companies use Jenkins X?
What companies use Red Hat OpenShift?
See which teams inside your own company are using Jenkins X or Red Hat OpenShift.
Sign up for StackShare EnterpriseLearn More

Sign up to get full access to all the companiesMake informed product decisions

What tools integrate with Jenkins X?
What tools integrate with Red Hat OpenShift?

Sign up to get full access to all the tool integrationsMake informed product decisions

What are some alternatives to Jenkins X and Red Hat OpenShift?
Jenkins
In a nutshell Jenkins CI is the leading open-source continuous integration server. Built with Java, it provides over 300 plugins to support building and testing virtually any project.
Spinnaker
Created at Netflix, it has been battle-tested in production by hundreds of teams over millions of deployments. It combines a powerful and flexible pipeline management system with integrations to the major cloud providers.
Blue Ocean
Designed from the ground up for Jenkins Pipeline and compatible with Freestyle jobs, Blue Ocean reduces clutter and increases clarity for every member of your team.
GitLab CI
GitLab offers a continuous integration service. If you add a .gitlab-ci.yml file to the root directory of your repository, and configure your GitLab project to use a Runner, then each merge request or push triggers your CI pipeline.
GitLab
GitLab offers git repository management, code reviews, issue tracking, activity feeds and wikis. Enterprises install GitLab on-premise and connect it with LDAP and Active Directory servers for secure authentication and authorization. A single GitLab server can handle more than 25,000 users but it is also possible to create a high availability setup with multiple active servers.
See all alternatives