Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
Akka vs Orleans: What are the differences?
Introduction: Akka and Orleans are two popular frameworks used for building distributed applications. While both frameworks provide similar functionality, there are key differences between Akka and Orleans that developers should consider when choosing a framework for their application.
Programming Model: Akka follows an actor-based programming model, where actors are lightweight concurrent entities that process messages asynchronously. Orleans, on the other hand, uses the concept of virtual actors, which are similar to actors but provide transparent and automatic scaling and distribution of the actor instances.
Language Support: Akka is primarily built for the Java and Scala programming languages, although there are also unofficial ports for other languages. Orleans, on the other hand, is built specifically for the .NET platform, with support for languages such as C# and F#.
Fault Tolerance: Akka provides a hierarchical supervision model that allows for the monitoring and recovery of actors in case of failures. This model provides fine-grained control over fault tolerance strategies. Orleans, on the other hand, provides a more simplified fault-tolerance model, where the runtime system handles fault detection and recovery transparently.
Dynamic Reconfiguration: Akka supports dynamic reconfiguration of actors, where actors can be added, removed, or modified during runtime without requiring a system restart. Orleans also supports dynamic reconfiguration, allowing for the addition or removal of actor instances without downtime.
Data Persistence: Akka provides built-in support for event sourcing and persistence, allowing actors to store and recover their internal state. Orleans, on the other hand, does not provide built-in support for data persistence, although it can be integrated with external data storage systems.
Community and Ecosystem: Akka has a larger and more established community with a wide range of libraries and tools available. It has been used in production by many companies and has a strong ecosystem. Orleans, while growing in popularity, has a smaller community and ecosystem compared to Akka.
In summary, the key differences between Akka and Orleans lie in their programming model, language support, fault tolerance strategies, dynamic reconfiguration capabilities, data persistence support, and the size and maturity of their respective communities and ecosystems.
Pros of Akka
- Great concurrency model32
- Fast17
- Actor Library12
- Open source10
- Resilient7
- Message driven5
- Scalable5
Pros of Orleans
- Akka.net alternative6
- Async/Await6
- Virtual Actor Model5
- Scalable5
- Distributed high-scale computing applications5
- Open source5
- Distributed ACID Transactions5
- Objects4
- Cross Platform4
- Distributed Locking4
- Fast2
- Great concurrency model1
- Message driven1
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of Akka
- Mixing futures with Akka tell is difficult3
- Closing of futures2
- No type safety2
- Very difficult to refactor1
- Typed actors still not stable1