Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

SonarQube

1.7K
2K
+ 1
52
WhiteSource

23
66
+ 1
0
Add tool

SonarQube vs WhiteSource: What are the differences?

Introduction

SonarQube and WhiteSource are two popular tools used for code analysis and vulnerability management in software development projects. While both aim to improve code quality and security, there are several key differences between these two tools.

  1. Scope of analysis: SonarQube is primarily focused on code quality analysis and provides detailed reports on code smells, bugs, vulnerabilities, and code duplications. It helps developers identify and fix issues in their code. On the other hand, WhiteSource goes beyond code analysis and offers a comprehensive software composition analysis (SCA) solution. It not only analyzes the project's source code but also identifies vulnerabilities and security risks arising from open-source libraries and external dependencies used in the project.

  2. Integration and support for different programming languages: SonarQube supports a wide range of programming languages, including popular ones like Java, C#, JavaScript, Python, and PHP. It provides language-specific analyzers to perform in-depth analysis. WhiteSource, on the other hand, focuses more on the analysis of open-source libraries and therefore supports a broader range of programming languages, including niche ones and even those with limited community support.

  3. Automation and CI/CD integration: SonarQube offers seamless integration with popular CI/CD tools like Jenkins and Azure DevOps, allowing developers to automate code quality checks as part of their continuous integration and delivery processes. WhiteSource also provides CI/CD integrations, but its main focus is on scanning and managing the security of open-source components used in the project, making it an important tool for DevSecOps teams.

  4. Licensing and pricing model: SonarQube's core features are available as an open-source tool, making it cost-effective for small teams or organizations with limited budgets. However, it also offers a paid version called SonarQube Developer Edition, which adds extra features and support. On the other hand, WhiteSource is a commercial product with different pricing tiers based on the organization's size and needs. Its pricing is primarily based on the number of developers and the level of support required.

  5. Deployment options and scalability: SonarQube can be self-hosted on-premises or deployed in the cloud using platforms like AWS, Azure, or GCP. It offers scalability options to handle large codebases and supports distributed analysis with multiple SonarQube instances. WhiteSource, on the other hand, is a cloud-based solution with no on-premises deployment option. It can easily scale to support small to large enterprises, but the cloud-based nature might not be suitable for organizations with strict data privacy or regulatory requirements.

  6. Focus on open source security: While both SonarQube and WhiteSource provide security analysis, WhiteSource has a stronger focus on open-source security. It provides vulnerability alerts, remediation suggestions, and license compliance checks specifically for open-source libraries used in the project. This specialized attention to identifying and addressing vulnerabilities in open-source components sets WhiteSource apart from SonarQube.

In Summary, SonarQube primarily focuses on code quality analysis across multiple programming languages, while WhiteSource goes beyond code analysis and specializes in identifying vulnerabilities and security risks in open-source libraries used in a project. It offers a comprehensive software composition analysis (SCA) solution and integrates seamlessly with CI/CD processes. SonarQube has a broader language support and offers both open-source and paid versions, while WhiteSource is a commercial tool with cloud-based deployment and a strong emphasis on open-source security.

Advice on SonarQube and WhiteSource
Bryan Dady
SRE Manager at Subsplash · | 5 upvotes · 436.7K views

I'm beginning to research the right way to better integrate how we achieve SCA / shift-left / SecureDevOps / secure software supply chain. If you use or have evaluated WhiteSource, Snyk, Sonatype Nexus, SonarQube or similar, I would very much appreciate your perspective on strengths and weaknesses and how you selected your ultimate solution. I want to integrate with GitLab CI.

See more
Replies (1)
Moises Figueroa
DevOps Engineer at Ingenium Code · | 2 upvotes · 31K views
Recommends

I'd recommend Snyk since it provides an IDE extension for Developers, SAST, auto PR security fixes, container, IaC and includes open source scanning as well. I like their scoring method as well for better prioritization. I was able to remove most of the containers and cli tools I had in my pipelines since Snyk covers secrets, vulns, security and some code cleaning. SAST has false positives but the scoring helps. Also had to spend time putting some training docs but their engineers helped out with content.

See more
Get Advice from developers at your company using StackShare Enterprise. Sign up for StackShare Enterprise.
Learn More
Pros of SonarQube
Pros of WhiteSource
  • 26
    Tracks code complexity and smell trends
  • 16
    IDE Integration
  • 9
    Complete code Review
  • 1
    Difficult to deploy
    Be the first to leave a pro

    Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions

    Cons of SonarQube
    Cons of WhiteSource
    • 7
      Sales process is long and unfriendly
    • 7
      Paid support is poor, techs arrogant and unhelpful
    • 1
      Does not integrate with Snyk
      Be the first to leave a con

      Sign up to add or upvote consMake informed product decisions

      - No public GitHub repository available -

      What is SonarQube?

      SonarQube provides an overview of the overall health of your source code and even more importantly, it highlights issues found on new code. With a Quality Gate set on your project, you will simply fix the Leak and start mechanically improving.

      What is WhiteSource?

      The leading solution for agile open source security and license compliance management, WhiteSource integrates with the DevOps pipeline to detect vulnerable open source libraries in real-time.

      Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

      What companies use SonarQube?
      What companies use WhiteSource?
      See which teams inside your own company are using SonarQube or WhiteSource.
      Sign up for StackShare EnterpriseLearn More

      Sign up to get full access to all the companiesMake informed product decisions

      What tools integrate with SonarQube?
      What tools integrate with WhiteSource?

      Sign up to get full access to all the tool integrationsMake informed product decisions

      What are some alternatives to SonarQube and WhiteSource?
      ReSharper
      It is a popular developer productivity extension for Microsoft Visual Studio. It automates most of what can be automated in your coding routines. It finds compiler errors, runtime errors, redundancies, and code smells right as you type, suggesting intelligent corrections for them.
      Checkmarx
      It is a provider of state-of-the-art application security solution: static code analysis software, seamlessly integrated into development process.
      Codacy
      Codacy automates code reviews and monitors code quality on every commit and pull request on more than 40 programming languages reporting back the impact of every commit or PR, issues concerning code style, best practices and security.
      FindBugs
      It detects possible bugs in Java programs. Potential errors are classified in four ranks: scariest, scary, troubling and of concern. This is a hint to the developer about their possible impact or severity.
      Veracode
      It seamlessly integrates application security into the software lifecycle, effectively eliminating vulnerabilities during the lowest-cost point in the development/deployment chain, and blocking threats while in production.
      See all alternatives