Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

Ninject

351
15
+ 1
0
Unity

1.8K
1.4K
+ 1
73
Add tool

Ninject vs Unity: What are the differences?

Introduction In the world of software development, dependency injection (DI) containers play a crucial role in managing dependencies and facilitating the creation of complex applications. Two popular DI containers that are widely used are Ninject and Unity. While both of these containers serve a similar purpose, there are several key differences between them that differentiate their functionalities and usage.

  1. Configuration: One noticeable difference between Ninject and Unity is their approach to configuration. Ninject relies on a fluent interface for configuration, allowing developers to build bindings using a series of method calls. On the other hand, Unity utilizes XML-based configuration or programmatic configuration through the Unity API, providing more flexibility in defining and managing dependencies.

  2. Lifecycle Management: Another key difference between Ninject and Unity lies in their approach to managing the lifecycle of dependencies. Ninject offers several built-in lifecycle management options such as transient, singleton, and a variety of custom scopes. In contrast, Unity provides a Unity Container that supports HierarchicalLifetimeManager, PerThreadLifetimeManager, and several other built-in lifetime managers, enabling developers to choose the most suitable option for their specific needs.

  3. Extensibility: Both Ninject and Unity offer extensibility, but with different approaches. Ninject allows developers to easily extend the container by creating custom modules, which encapsulate bindings and configurations. Unity, on the other hand, offers extension points through a container extension mechanism, enabling developers to add new functionality to the container by implementing the IUnityContainerExtension interface.

  4. Interception: Interception is a powerful feature that allows developers to insert code before and after method invocations. Ninject provides a built-in interception mechanism called Interception Extensions, which allows developers to apply interception to classes or interfaces without modifying the original code. Unity, on the other hand, relies on a separate Unity.Interception library to provide interception capabilities, requiring some additional setup and configuration.

  5. Documentation and Community: The availability of documentation and a supportive community can significantly impact the development experience. While both Ninject and Unity have extensive documentation, Unity has a larger community and more extensive resources due to its association with Microsoft. This larger community translates into more available resources, tutorials, and online forums to seek help or guidance from when using Unity.

  6. Integration with the Ecosystem: Lastly, Ninject and Unity differ in terms of their integration with other frameworks and tools. Ninject has a smaller ecosystem, which means it may have fewer integrations with popular tools and frameworks. On the other hand, Unity has a wider ecosystem and is often the preferred DI container for .NET applications due to its close integration with other Microsoft technologies like ASP.NET and Azure.

In Summary, Ninject and Unity differ in their approach to configuration, lifecycle management, extensibility, interception, documentation and community support, and integration with the ecosystem.

Decisions about Ninject and Unity
norlin
Software Engineer / Game Developer at Norlin Games · | 7 upvotes · 86.2K views

When I started to learn game development, I've tried to use Unity multiple times because it's the most popular option. But never get it worked because of the clunky UI which is very hard to understand for a new user. After some time, I've decided to try UE4 despite there was a lot of rumors that it's "heavy" or requires an AAA team. And suddenly it clicked, everything works as I expecting, UI is clear and much more powerfull, no need to build custom tools to work on the game itself. Blueprints are very helpful for beginners, C++ has a lot of "syntax-sugar" - macroses, a lot of convenient in-engine types for everything. Later while working with Unreal, I've realized it has very consistent roadmap with constant improvements and adding new features. At the same time, each major version update is painless so you can upgrade your project during development to get new features. UE4 is free to use with the full list of features and you only have to pay royalty after getting your first $1 million from the project (and that's just the default case, you can always discuss custom license with an upfront fee, if you want to).

See more
Arthur Osipyan
Software Engineer at Value Industry · | 2 upvotes · 83.7K views

I chose Unity over Unreal Engine because Unity has a more user friendly UI for beginners looking to learn game development. Additionally, as someone who uses a lot of online resources to learn new languages and tools, I found a lot of tutorials covering game development with Unity as the core engine. This doesn't mean Unreal is not a great choice for game development, I just personally found learning game development much smoother with the amount of resources available with Unity.

See more
Get Advice from developers at your company using StackShare Enterprise. Sign up for StackShare Enterprise.
Learn More
Pros of Ninject
Pros of Unity
    Be the first to leave a pro
    • 16
      Because it's a powerful engine, you can build anything
    • 14
      C# language
    • 11
      Very Popular
    • 7
      Easy to Use
    • 6
      He Has A Free VErsion
    • 6
      Cross Platform
    • 5
      2nd Game Engine In The World
    • 4
      Good Choise
    • 4
      Very Large Showcase

    Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions

    Cons of Ninject
    Cons of Unity
      Be the first to leave a con
      • 4
        Hard to get started with
      • 4
        Clunky UI
      • 4
        Closed source
      • 3
        No consistency with updates
      • 3
        Requires to build a lot of tools
      • 2
        Gigantic by being 9gb (thats what setup says)

      Sign up to add or upvote consMake informed product decisions

      - No public GitHub repository available -

      What is Ninject?

      It is a lightning-fast, ultra-lightweight dependency injector for .NET applications. It helps you split your application into a collection of loosely-coupled, highly-cohesive pieces, and then glue them back together in a flexible manner. By using it to support your software's architecture, your code will become easier to write, reuse, test, and modify.

      What is Unity?

      Unity is the ultimate game development platform. Use Unity to build high-quality 3D and 2D games, deploy them across mobile, desktop, VR/AR, consoles or the Web, and connect with loyal and enthusiastic players and customers.

      Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

      What companies use Ninject?
      What companies use Unity?
      See which teams inside your own company are using Ninject or Unity.
      Sign up for StackShare EnterpriseLearn More

      Sign up to get full access to all the companiesMake informed product decisions

      What tools integrate with Ninject?
      What tools integrate with Unity?

      Sign up to get full access to all the tool integrationsMake informed product decisions

      Blog Posts

      Vue.jsSpring BootUnity+7
      2
      1190
      What are some alternatives to Ninject and Unity?
      Bundler
      It provides a consistent environment for Ruby projects by tracking and installing the exact gems and versions that are needed. It is an exit from dependency hell, and ensures that the gems you need are present in development, staging, and production.
      three.js
      It is a cross-browser JavaScript library and Application Programming Interface used to create and display animated 3D computer graphics in a web browser.
      Unreal Engine
      It is a game engine that helps you make games. It is made up of several components that work together to drive the game. Its massive system of tools and editors allows you to organize your assets and manipulate them to create the gameplay for your game.
      Godot
      It is an advanced, feature-packed, multi-platform 2D and 3D open source game engine. It is developed by hundreds of contributors from all around the world.
      Phaser
      It is a free open source HTML5 game framework. It uses Pixi.js for WebGL and Canvas rendering across desktop and mobile web browsers. Games can be compiled to iOS and Android apps via 3rd party tools.
      See all alternatives