Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
Lumen vs Symfony: What are the differences?
Introduction
Lumen and Symfony are both popular PHP frameworks used for web application development. While they share some similarities, there are several key differences between the two.
Performance: Lumen is designed to be lightweight and fast, making it a suitable choice for microservices and API development. It prioritizes performance and efficiency, which allows for quicker response times and better scalability compared to Symfony.
Ease of Use: Lumen offers a simpler and more streamlined development experience, catering to developers who prefer a minimalistic approach. It provides a concise syntax and a reduced feature set, making it easier to learn and use for small to medium-sized projects. Symfony, on the other hand, is a more comprehensive framework with a steeper learning curve but offers a wider range of features and flexibility for complex applications.
Documentation and Community: Symfony has a larger and more established community compared to Lumen. This results in a wealth of documentation, tutorials, and resources available, making it easier for developers to find assistance and solutions to their problems. Lumen, being a more lightweight framework, has a smaller community but still provides ample documentation and support.
Application Size and Dependencies: Lumen has a smaller footprint and fewer dependencies compared to Symfony. This makes it ideal for projects that prioritize minimalism and small application size. Symfony, being a more feature-rich framework, has a larger number of dependencies and a larger footprint, making it more suitable for larger and more complex projects.
Integration: Symfony is known for its seamless integration with other libraries and packages. It has a robust ecosystem of third-party components and bundles that can be easily integrated into Symfony applications. Lumen, being a micro-framework, does not offer the same level of pre-built integrations and relies more on custom development for integrating additional functionalities.
Customization and Extensibility: Symfony allows for extensive customization and offers a high degree of extensibility through its bundle system. Developers can easily add, remove, or modify functionality using bundles, making it highly adaptable for a wide range of projects. Lumen, while still customizable, has a more limited set of features and a smaller number of extensions available, restricting the level of customization and extensibility.
In Summary, Lumen is a more lightweight and performant PHP framework with a simpler syntax, ideal for smaller projects that prioritize speed and minimalism. Symfony, on the other hand, is a comprehensive framework with a larger community, extensive documentation, and a wide range of integrations, making it suitable for larger and more complex projects that require flexibility and scalability.
I'm about to begin working on an API, for which I plan to add GraphQL connectivity for processing data. The data processed will mainly be audio files being downloaded/uploaded with some user messaging & authentication.
I don't mind the difficulty in any service since I've used C++ (for data structures & algorithms at least) and would also say I am patient and can learn fairly quickly. My main concerns would be their performance, libraries/community, and job marketability.
Why I'm stuck between these three...
Symfony: I've programmed in PHP for back-end in a previous internship and may do so again in a few months.
Node.js: It's newer than PHP, and it's JavaScript where my front-end stack will be React and (likely) React Native.
Go: It's newer than PHP, I've heard of its good performance, and it would be nice to learn a new (growing) language.
Go with Node.js. There's something really satisfying about being able to use a single language across your entire tech stack. Especially once you integrate GraphQL, which is effectively JSON.
Your second best option is Go, but the ecosystem around Node.js is quite a bit stronger. This will play a big factor when you start building functionality like file management, messaging (especially in real-time), and authentication. The libraries and documentation are just stronger for Node.
Pros of Lumen
- API38
- Microframework28
- MVC19
- PHP16
- Open source12
- Eloquent11
- Restful & fast framework10
- Composer8
- Illuminate support7
- Brother of laravel and fast4
- Easy to learn4
- Fast4
Pros of Symfony
- Open source177
- Php149
- Community130
- Dependency injection129
- Professional122
- Doctrine80
- Organized75
- Modular architecture71
- Smart programming47
- Solid45
- Documentation20
- LTS releases16
- Decoupled framework components10
- Robust10
- Easy to Learn10
- Good practices guideline8
- Service container8
- Bundle8
- Powerful7
- Simple7
- Flexible6
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of Lumen
- Not fast3
- PHP2
- Not fast with MongoDB1
Cons of Symfony
- Too many dependency10
- Lot of config files8
- YMAL4
- Feature creep3
- Bloated1