Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
Apache Allura vs GitHub Enterprise: What are the differences?
Introduction
Apache Allura and GitHub Enterprise are two popular platforms used for hosting and managing software repositories. While they have similarities in their core functionality, there are some key differences between them that make them suitable for different use cases. In this article, we will explore six key differences between Apache Allura and GitHub Enterprise.
Hosting: Apache Allura is open-source and can be self-hosted on any server, allowing complete control over the hosting environment. On the other hand, GitHub Enterprise is a cloud-based solution offered by GitHub, providing a fully managed hosting infrastructure.
Licensing: Apache Allura is released under an open-source license, allowing users to modify and distribute the software freely. GitHub Enterprise, however, requires a commercial license, which comes with a fee. This can be a significant factor for organizations with specific licensing requirements.
Feature Set: Both Apache Allura and GitHub Enterprise offer similar core features, such as version control, issue tracking, and collaboration tools. However, GitHub Enterprise provides a more comprehensive and user-friendly feature set, including code review capabilities, advanced search functionality, and integrations with popular development tools.
Integration: GitHub Enterprise has deep integrations with other GitHub products and services, such as GitHub Actions, GitHub Packages, and GitHub Pages. These integrations provide seamless workflows for development, testing, and deployment processes. While Apache Allura supports some integrations, it may not have the same level of integration and ecosystem as GitHub Enterprise.
Community: Apache Allura has a smaller community compared to GitHub Enterprise. GitHub Enterprise has a vast user base and a thriving community, which means there are more resources, tutorials, and community-driven plugins available. This can be advantageous for developers looking for support or additional functionalities.
Pricing: Apache Allura being an open-source software is free to use and does not have any licensing fees. In contrast, GitHub Enterprise requires a commercial license, which comes with a cost. The pricing for GitHub Enterprise depends on factors such as the number of users and the level of support required.
In summary, Apache Allura and GitHub Enterprise differ in terms of hosting options, licensing, feature set, integration capabilities, community support, and pricing. Organizations looking for a self-hosted, open-source solution with minimal costs may prefer Apache Allura, while those seeking a fully managed, commercially supported platform with a robust feature set may opt for GitHub Enterprise.
We are using a Bitbucket server, and due to migration efforts and new Atlassian community license changes, we need to move to a new self-hosted solution. The new data-center license for Atlassian, available in February, will be community provisioned (free). Along with that community license, other technologies will be coming with it (Crucible, Confluence, and Jira). Is there value in a paid-for license to get the GitHub Enterprise? Are the tools that come with it worth the cost?
I know it is about $20 per 10 seats, and we have about 300 users. Have other convertees to Microsoft's tools found it easy to do a migration? Is the toolset that much more beneficial to the free suite that one can get from Atlassian?
So far, free seems to be the winner, and the familiarization with Atlassian implementation and maintenance is understood. Going to GitHub, are there any distinct challenges to be found or any perks to be attained?
These are pretty competitive, and to recommend one over the other would require understanding your usage. Also, what other tools you use: for instance, what do you use for Issue-tracking, or for build pipelines. In your case, since you are already using Bitbucket, the question would be: do you have any current pain-points? And, on the other hand, do you already use Atlassian's JIRA, where you'd benefit from the tight integration? So, though I would not recommend one over the other just in general,. But, if Bitbucket fulfills your current use-cases, then there seems to be little motivation to move.
Pros of Apache Allura
Pros of GitHub Enterprise
- Expensive - $$$4
- Code security2
- CDCI with Github Actions2
- Both Cloud and Enterprise Server Versions available1
- Draft Pull Request1
- User experience0
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of Apache Allura
Cons of GitHub Enterprise
- $$$2
