Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
Docker vs Salt: What are the differences?
Isolation: Docker focuses on creating isolated containers that encapsulate applications and their dependencies, ensuring consistency and portability across different environments. On the other hand, Salt is more geared towards configuration management and automation, allowing for efficient management of infrastructure and network devices.
Purpose: Docker is primarily used for packaging and deploying applications in lightweight, portable containers, making it easy to scale and manage distributed applications. In contrast, Salt is designed for orchestrating infrastructure, automating configuration changes, and ensuring uniformity across servers and devices in a network.
Architecture: Docker follows a client-server architecture where Docker Engine manages containers and images, while Salt utilizes a master-minion architecture where the Salt master controls and communicates with Salt minions on target systems. This distinction affects how tasks are executed and managed within each system.
Ease of Use: Docker provides a user-friendly interface and commands for managing containers, images, and networks, making it accessible to developers and system administrators. Salt, on the other hand, requires a deeper understanding of configuration files, states, and pillars to effectively automate and manage infrastructure, which may have a steeper learning curve.
Community Support: Docker boasts a large community of users and contributors, leading to a wealth of resources, plugins, and integrations that enhance its capabilities. Salt also has a strong community backing, with a focus on infrastructure automation, networking, and cloud orchestration, providing support for a wide range of use cases and environments.
Scalability: Docker excels in containerization and scaling applications horizontally, allowing for efficient resource utilization and deployment in microservices architectures. In contrast, Salt is more suited for managing configurations and enforcing policies across a large number of servers or network devices, providing a robust solution for infrastructure automation at scale.
In Summary, Docker and Salt serve different purposes in the realm of DevOps, with Docker focusing on containerization for application deployment and scalability, while Salt specializes in infrastructure automation and configuration management.
lxd/lxc and Docker aren't congruent so this comparison needs a more detailed look; but in short I can say: the lxd-integrated administration of storage including zfs with its snapshot capabilities as well as the system container (multi-process) approach of lxc vs. the limited single-process container approach of Docker is the main reason I chose lxd over Docker.
Pros of Docker
- Rapid integration and build up823
- Isolation692
- Open source521
- Testability and reproducibility505
- Lightweight460
- Standardization218
- Scalable185
- Upgrading / downgrading / application versions106
- Security88
- Private paas environments85
- Portability34
- Limit resource usage26
- Game changer17
- I love the way docker has changed virtualization16
- Fast14
- Concurrency12
- Docker's Compose tools8
- Easy setup6
- Fast and Portable6
- Because its fun5
- Makes shipping to production very simple4
- Highly useful3
- It's dope3
- Package the environment with the application2
- Super2
- Open source and highly configurable2
- Simplicity, isolation, resource effective2
- MacOS support FAKE2
- Its cool2
- Does a nice job hogging memory2
- Docker hub for the FTW2
- HIgh Throughput2
- Very easy to setup integrate and build2
- Asdfd0
Pros of Salt
- Flexible46
- Easy30
- Remote execution27
- Enormously flexible24
- Great plugin API12
- Python10
- Extensible5
- Scalable3
- nginx2
- Vagrant provisioner1
- HipChat1
- Best IaaC1
- Automatisation1
- Parallel Execution1
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of Docker
- New versions == broken features8
- Unreliable networking6
- Documentation not always in sync6
- Moves quickly4
- Not Secure3
Cons of Salt
- Bloated1
- Dangerous1
- No immutable infrastructure1